Her name was Valerie Passerieux, and she was an artist. If you looked up “artist” in a dictionary, you may very well have found a photograph of her under the heading. Standing a slight 5 foot 5 with long blonde hair, one green eye and one blue eye, and a playful French accent, she seemed cast for the part from birth. Her room and entire house were decorated with her work; plaster busts of African women inspired by a trip to Morocco, some unique texture-oriented abstracts that had been part of a school project, paintings and sketches of local towns and statues, and even a self portrait. Walking into the tiny house that she shared with her mother was like walking into an exposition hall.
I first met Valerie through her mother, Marie-France. A school teacher by trade, Marie-France was uncommonly quiet and kept herself aloof. She didn’t interact socially with anyone in particular at church, was not close with her colleagues at school, and didn’t really seem to have any friends. The only thing that seemed to get her talking even a little was to bring up Valerie’s many artistic accomplishments. I had just been transferred to Bergerac two weeks before Christmas 1996, and I wasn’t adjusting well. It took a little while for me to warm up to Marie-France, as she didn’t seem very interested in wanting to get to know me or anyone else any better and I really didn’t care to hear any more about her daughter’s talents. Besides, she seemed very distant all the time and seemed to want to be left alone. In my twenty year-old head, I figured that it wasn’t worth beating my head against the wall trying to get her to open up. After all, I was a stranger in a strange land, and six months from that point I would more than likely be in another country and far away from Marie-France and her child prodigy. She seemed so closed off and secretive all the time, and I couldn’t understand why. As I would learn, Marie-France had her reasons.
As a few weeks went by, I found myself spending more time with Marie-France at church. She had three callings and spent most of her time outside of work running the genealogical library. I can’t remember exactly what happened or when, but suddenly one day I found myself wanting to reach out to her. I can remember watching her bent over the light table, quietly examining microfilms, and knowing that she needed a friend. Nothing had been said up to that point and nothing ever really would, but over the Christmas holidays we would begin to forge a relationship that would stay with me for much longer that the seven months I would be part of her life.
Just before Christmas, Marie-France invited us over for dinner. She was going to the Pyrenees mountains to spend Christmas with her children, Valerie and Eric. Neither lived at home, and it was an opportunity for her to spend some quality time with them. It would quickly become very clear that her children were the centre of her universe. When I walked through the front door, I couldn’t help but look around at the collection of art that seemed to take up every available square foot of wall space. I couldn’t find a piece of furniture without a sculpture on it, and even the corners were occupied by canvasses and paintings in various stages of completion. To my surprise, the art was very good. I was impressed, and began to understand Marie-France’s pride in her daughter’s work. The paintings, in particular, were beautiful. During dinner, Marie-France actually talked to us about herself for the first time. Her life had not been an easy one, starting with her childhood and culminating in a very difficult divorce a few years earlier. As she spoke, I felt a strange sort of connection to her, like I could somehow relate to the pain and frustration she was feeling. I left her house that night trying to figure out how to help her.
I had planned to speak with her on Sunday at church and ask her if there was anything we could help her with, but that all changed when I met Valerie. She was home visiting her mother for the weekend and had come to church with her to meet the new missionaries. When she came into the room, it was like someone somewhere had turned a light on, and all I could see was her. It scared me a little. I don’t believe in love at first sight, and to complicate matters even further, I still had another six months remaining in my mission and was prohibited from getting involved with anyone until I went home. Luckily, she had an easygoing way about her that disarmed me and put me at ease. I ended up talking with her well after the church meetings ended. When I left, I felt like I had known her for years.
I would only see Valerie periodically for the next month. Christmas came and went, leaving in its wake a grey and rainy European winter. It was a cold and cheerless month of January, and we worked hard. The town of Bergerac had been canvassed dozens of times over by previous legions of missionaries, and the work was slow and difficult as we struggled to find people to teach. I began to have difficulty sleeping, and found that it was an ailment I shared with Marie-France. She recommended that I try magnesium supplements, which I did with limited success. I began to spend a lot of time on the phone with her late at night, and learned a lot about the trials and experiences that had shaped her into the person I was slowly getting to know. I also began to learn more about Valerie. At first it was innocent comments, but ultimately I found myself fishing for information. I knew that I couldn’t pursue a relationship with her, but I wanted to know more about this creative blonde girl that had sparked my interest.
As January waned, Valerie began to come home more often. Coincidentally, it seemed that every time Marie-France invited us over for dinner, Valerie would be there. One day, out of the blue, Valerie called me to ask about something we had discussed the previous weekend, and the phone call ended up stretching into an hour-long conversation. The next morning, I awoke to the realization that I was developing feelings for Valerie and that as a missionary, I was treading on dangerous ground. I resolved to keep the friendship in check, and began to put up a wall between Valerie and myself. She noticed immediately and seemed to be hurt, although we continued to speak regularly. Within a week, Marie-France asked me why I was being so distant. I explained to her the position I was in, knowing full well that the information would be relayed. A week later I received a card from Valerie telling me that she understood and would keep her distance, but that if I was interested in giving things a shot when my mission was finished, she would be around. She kept her word and our friendship remained appropriate as we continued to get to know each other. As the end grew closer, however, it became more difficult to maintain the necessary distance. Even though I was not supposed to correspond with any women within mission boundaries, letters became the only way for us to speak candidly with each other and we began to write to each other more frequently. Valerie began to limit her visits home to every two weeks, as it was becoming difficult for us to ignore the physical and emotional tension that was developing between us. With six weeks left in my mission, I was relieved when I was transferred to another area to prepare for a traveling musical that I was involved in. Thankfully, the last month and a half went quickly. The musical was touring western France doing a show every second night, with practices and travel in between. It was hectic but provided a much needed focus. In the four months and change I had spent in Bergerac, I had formed a friendship with Valerie that felt like it was decades old. The more I had gotten to know her, the more I had found myself caring for her. I was now in the unenviable position of having found someone I wanted to be with but being unable to do so. I did my best to push Valerie from my mind and concentrate on finishing my mission with dedicated effort.
In mid-May 1997, my parents came to France to pick me up as my mission ended. We spent two weeks visiting the various areas I had served in, and not surprisingly, I found myself back in Bergerac. Free from the restrictions that had defined our friendship from the beginning, things became awkward between Valerie and I as we struggled to adjust to the continuation of a growing relationship in a “normal” context. After over two years of keeping everyone at a distance emotionally and spiritually, I found myself unsure of how to actually let someone get close to me. I felt like a twelve year-old kid again, learning how to act around girls. During the second week, Valerie accompanied my parents and me to Arcachon, on the west coast of France. As we were climbing the giant sand dune that draws people to the town, Valerie stumbled and reached out for my hand. Instinctively, I caught it and helped her back to her feet. As she caught her balance, she squeezed my hand but didn’t let go. It was electrifying but frightening for me as I reminded myself that I wasn’t a missionary anymore and that this was OK now. Later that afternoon we raced each other down the seaward side of the dune as my parents waited on top. As we reached the water’s edge, Valerie threw her arms around me and laughed. At that moment, I wanted nothing more than to stay there with her forever.
Reality called me back two days later as we left for Paris to return to Canada. My mission’s boundaries did not include Paris and I had never been there, but my excitement at visiting the city of light was dampened by the feeling of loss as I said goodbye to Valerie and Marie-France. They felt like a second family to me, and it was very difficult to leave them. I didn’t know it at the time, but it was the last time I would see Marie-France. I spent a wonderful day in Paris with my parents, but couldn’t shake the feeling that my world was collapsing. That night, I called Valerie from a pay phone to tell her that I didn’t want to leave. I felt like the plane would be taking me away from everything I now found familiar, and I was afraid that the connection we felt would die on the vine once we were on opposite sides of the world. The next day, under a blanket of grey skies and pouring rain, I walked on to an Air Canada Boeing 747 and flew away from Valerie, Bergerac, and the life I had known for over two years. As the plane lifted off from Charles DeGaulle airport, I felt my stomach flip-flop uncomfortably. Victor Hugo once said “Every man has two countries, and once of them is France.” At that moment, I knew that part of me would always remain there.
Two months later, another Air Canada plane landed in Calgary, Alberta. When Valerie cleared customs and walked out to meet me, I felt like I hadn’t seen her in years. To me, it felt like she was coming home. For some reason, that still scared me a little bit. The drive back to Lethbridge calmed my fears, and I felt like I had been given a second chance to have Valerie as a part of my life. Being with her seemed familiar; even more familiar than the prairie landscapes that had been my home for 19 years before going to France. She brought one of her paintings as a gift for my parents; a watercolour of the medieval marketplace at Sarlat la Caneda where we had eaten lunch together months before. When they hung it on their bedroom wall, it seemed to belong in our home.
Valerie stayed with my family for almost two months. We took her everywhere we could think of that might be interesting to someone visiting Canada. Although I enjoyed the time we spent together, to me it seemed almost as though we were trying to sell the country to her. She became close with my mother and went hiking with her once a week while I was at work. Our relationship was no longer awkward and was becoming serious. It seemed like all the pieces were falling into place. The first week she was with me had brought back some of the hesitation I had experienced as I tried to allow myself to interact with her as a man, not a missionary. The four weeks in the middle were bliss. Valerie was becoming my best friend. We had so much in common that it seemed there wasn’t time to discuss it all, and we enjoyed each others’ company. Knowing that our time together was limited, we tried to make the most of it. For much of the time we were together nearly 24/7. I was also staying in touch with Marie-France, who seemed elated that things were going so well between me and Valerie. It was almost too perfect.
The first feelings of uneasiness began when I looked at the calendar and realized that Valerie would be going home in less that two weeks. Home to France, home to a world that seemed agonizingly out of my reach. She would get on a plane and fly away, and then what? When would we see each other again? Could we just keep our lives on hold until we could be together again? What if one of us met someone else? Long distance relationships are one thing when you see the person semi-regularly, but both of us had to know that it wasn’t realistic to keep flying back and forth between Canada and France. I began to wonder if I was doing the right thing.
With a week left in her stay, I began subconsciously building a wall between myself and Valerie. I didn’t want to, but I wasn’t sure how I would react to losing her for good and began to unwittingly prepare myself psychologically. She kept reaching out to me, and I kept pulling away. I’m sure she felt the change, but she didn’t let it show. She just kept doing all the things that made her so perfect for me, and I kept concentrating on all the reasons I could think of that we wouldn’t be good for each other. The summer was ending, and time began to rush by like a landscape viewed from a speeding car, carrying us both to the point of decision that we knew was coming but didn’t want to face.
With three days left, Valerie went out on a limb and told me she loved me. She planned to return to France and exhibit some of her art to raise money to return to Canada. She had fallen in love with the country and with my family and wanted to spend the rest of her life here with me. She hoped to return at Christmas, and hoped that by then we could get engaged and plan for her to move to Lethbridge permanently in the spring. I was left reeling. I thought that I loved her too and I did want to be with her, but I wasn’t ready to commit to marriage. The reality of having to lock everything in so suddenly shocked me, and I suddenly found myself guarded and wanting to take a step back from the relationship to gather my thoughts. Engaged by Christmas? I wanted to take time to enjoy the relationship we had formed, but realized that with the distance in play, time wasn’t a luxury we could afford. I suddenly felt rushed and trapped, and hated myself for hesitating. Try as I might, I couldn’t think of a reason not to commit to her, other than fear. I tried to water down my response and told her that I wanted her to come back at Christmas but felt like we should slow things down a little bit. The words sounded weak and unconvincing, and I could tell that she didn’t understand. She was ready for the next step and I was not, and that hurt her.
The next few days fell into an awkward space between a desire to enjoy our remaining time together and the guarded caution that accompanied the uncertainty of our future together. When her plane took off, I felt sad, confused, and angry with myself. The empty feeling was back again, and I couldn’t figure out why I had not been able to offer her something more solid. At the same time, I knew I wasn’t ready to commit to marriage. I became bitter at the distance and the obstacle it presented, and wanted to return to France. Most of all, I thought of Valerie and wondered if I would see her again.
As it turned out, the answer was no. When she got on the plane that day in Calgary, she walked out of my life forever. We continued to write regularly and spoke at least once a week, but by the end of September it was clear that the distance was already working its way between us. The letters became less frequent, the conversation began to stall, and we found that we were living parallel lives that no longer had much in common. She had begun a new series of paintings based on the prairies and grain elevators that had captured her while she was in Canada, and her art was taking up most of her time. I had begun playing in a band and was hanging out with people she didn’t know in places she had never been. To her credit, she held on faithfully and never questioned me. I tried to remember the connection we had and remind myself how good we were for each other, but I still couldn’t get past the feeling that I was not ready to commit to marriage. In the end, it began to hurt her. Although she never said anything outright, a change crept into her voice that told me that I had wounded her deeply. By mid-October, I could no longer allow myself to keep going through the motions. It wasn’t fair to her, and I cared for her enough to realize that I couldn’t make her wait forever. I agonized over the decision, convinced that I was about to throw away the most important thing in my life but convinced that it was the only fair thing to do. It took me four days to finish writing my thoughts and feelings down, but on a chilly fall day in Granum, Alberta, I left my job managing a campground and walked through the swirling leaves to the tiny post office where I mailed the letter that ended my relationship with Valerie Passerieux.
I don’t remember exactly what I said, but I remember the line from the song “Full of Grace” by Sarah McLachlan that I wrote at the end of the letter:
“I know I can love you much better than this, but it’s better this way”.
I spent the winter alone. Valerie continued to write to my mother, and sent photos of her grain elevator paintings. One of them in particular made me feel like it had been painted for me. It was dark and stormy, showing a single elevator amidst waving prairie grasses against a backdrop of a sky heavy with cloud. To this day, I wish I had that painting. Valerie continued to write to me occasionally, but I could tell that it was painful for her. In December 1998 I moved to Calgary, where I gradually fell out of touch with almost everyone I had known in France. The letter I had sent to her had not only removed Valerie from my life; it seemed that it had severed the connection between me and everything I had lived during my mission years. I began to feel the loss then, and I still feel it today. I made an effort to keep up contact with a few select people I had been closest to, and Valerie e-mailed me sporadically throughout the summer of 1999, then that too gradually died out. My mother still corresponded with her regularly, and seemed convinced that Valerie was waiting for me to reach out to her and resume our relationship. I never tried.
In 2000, Valerie moved in with a French military officer named Benoit. By that time she wasn’t much more than a footnote in my thoughts, and I married my wife in February 2001. In October 2002 I wrote a letter to Marie-France and got a response. At that time Valerie was now married to Benoit and they were living in La Reunion, expecting their first child. I sent another letter to Marie-France in early 2003 after the Bear was born, but never got a response. I think she has moved now, and I don’t know how to contact her. Likewise, I have no idea how to contact Valerie if I wanted to. I don’t know where she is, what she is doing, or how things are going for her. I am happy with my life, but sometimes I wonder how different things would be right now if I had made the decision to stay with her. I guess it just wasn’t meant to be. I wish I could talk to her again and maybe do a better job of explaining why I did what I did. I’m sure she doesn’t even think about it anymore, but I wish that I could just have one more conversation with her to clear the air and let her know that she really was a very important part of my life.
Everyone comes into your life for a reason, some people just stay in it longer than others. Valerie Passerieux, wherever you are now, I wish you well.